Tuesday, July 4

The book review as self-parody

This San Francisco Chronicle story is a fine parody of a South Asian book review:

Siddharth Shanghvi

Growing up in Bombay, Siddharth Dhanvant Shanghvi wasn’t a typical Indian schoolboy. Sensitive, precocious, exotically beautiful with eyes the color of nutmeg… His refuge was… a fragrant bakul tree… [Link]

His mehndi-tinged hair swoops over the sandalwood fragrance of his almond-shaped eyelids… his elephantine fingernails cry ‘koo-oo-oo! koo-oo-oo!’ like the koyal as they pluck at the first mangoes of spring.

Slap a sari on the border, another desi lit review’s in the can.

The fatuous author fawns over a dish so basic, it’s served to sick people. It’s like drooling over très exotique macaroni ‘n cheese:

“Do you like the khicadi?” he asks, referring to the latest dish to appear. “It’s rice and lentils boiled together, with a bit of masala.” It’s delicious, subtle… [Link]

I couldn’t tell whether the journalist wanted to review him or jump him (and that’s not a comment on sexuality, it’s a comment on professionalism):

… the combination of rich food, wine and nonstop chatter have exhausted him and turned his large brown eyes into droopy wet pools… [Link]

I haven’t read The Last Song of Dusk, but Kitabkhana once posted a very entertaining review:

… a passage where Dr Hariharan starts to beat his wife: “This went on with merciless delight–thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash, thrash–until with a pregnant woman’s ferocious instinct for survival, Mrs Hariharan fought back. Kicking, biting, clawing, kicking, biting, clawing, kicking, biting, clawing, kicking, biting, clawing, kicking, biting, clawing, kicking, biting, clawing, kicking, biting, clawing, kicking, biting, clawing, kicking, biting, clawing: as much as a woman with an infant stored in her womb could.”

… [Shanghvi] never had an editor… more than breathe on his manuscript for two seconds. Because any editor worth his or her salt would have “Begged him to delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete, delete…” [Link]

(via Sepia Mutiny)

Update: Kitabkhana turns the review into death by snarklink.

Related posts: The spices speak to me, Coffee cant, We’ve got a live one!, Sakina’s Restaurant, Anatomy of a genre, M-m-me so hungry, Buzzword bingo

Hoarding

5 comments

  1. 1A

    He read a sexually explicit exceprt of his book at Artwallah. Most people that I spoke to thought it was in poor taste to choose passage like that for a family show. On top of that he giggled a few times while getting through it. Giggling at your own sexually explicit writing = lame.

  2. 2chick pea

    too funny of a review… yeah, the interviewer totally wants to jump his bones… his eyes were droopy wet pools? holy smokes… my entertainment of the day. thanks MV. and yes, Mac&Chez can be exotic, if you use something besides the chedda ;).. how about some gouda… now that is supreme…

  3. 3Pooja

    how about some gouda…

    Or Asiago…
    Or Jarlsburg…
    Or Gruyere…

    (OK, I am hungry now.)

    I gave Shanghvi’s book a miss when it first came out, but after hearing him read an excerpt at ArtWallah, I am even less likely to pick it up.

  4. 4tashie

    Well… at least he is very pretty. Not really helping that stereotype of South Asian men as effeminate and exotic v much though, is he?

    Did they discuss the mustard coloured khadi shirt or was the interviewer much more concerned with the smooth mocha-coloured skin underneath it? Maybe we could ask Aishwarya if the special magic powers of mustard is what made him so alluring to Nice White Person who wrote the review.

    I wonder where he gets his eyebrows threaded…hmm…

  5. 5Msichana

    I read ‘The Last Song of Dusk’ a few months ago and am still reeling from a scene in which a teenage girl gets it on with a tiger. If that wasn’t baffling enough, this same girl also walks on water. I know better now…I should have read the book when slightly wasted.


Leave comment

   
    (not published)
   
    (link to profile)
   

Please don't feed the trolls.